Analysis11 min read Read

Why Your ChatGPT Prompts Aren't Working

PIEVOT Team•2025-12-19

You typed a thoughtful prompt. You hit enter. And ChatGPT gave you... garbage.

We've all been there. That moment of frustration when you're staring at a response that completely missed the point. But here's the thing: it's rarely the AI's fault.

Let me walk you through the most common reasons your prompts fail—and exactly how to fix each one.

The Diagnosis Framework

When a prompt fails, the problem usually falls into one of four categories:

              WHY PROMPTS FAIL
                    │
     ┌──────────────┼──────────────┐
     │              │              │
     ▼              ▼              ▼
┌─────────┐   ┌─────────┐   ┌─────────┐   ┌─────────┐
│ CLARITY │   │ CONTEXT │   │ SCOPE   │   │ EXPECT- │
│  ISSUE  │   │  ISSUE  │   │  ISSUE  │   │ ATIONS  │
└────┬────┘   └────┬────┘   └────┬────┘   └────┬────┘
     │             │             │             │
  Vague or      Missing       Too much      Asking the
  ambiguous     background    or too        impossible
  request       info          little

Let's diagnose each one.

Problem 1: Clarity Issues ("What Did You Even Ask?")

Symptoms:

•Response is technically correct but not what you wanted

•AI interpreted your request differently than you intended

•Output is generic and could apply to anyone

Root cause:

Your prompt has ambiguity. Words like "good," "better," "professional," or "creative" mean different things to different people—and the AI picks its own interpretation.

Example of the problem:

   YOUR PROMPT: "Make this email more professional"
   
   POSSIBLE INTERPRETATIONS:
   ┌─────────────────────────────────────────────┐
   │  1. More formal language                    │
   │  2. Better structure                        │
   │  3. Fewer typos                             │
   │  4. Remove slang                            │
   │  5. Add proper greeting/closing             │
   │  6. All of the above?                       │
   └─────────────────────────────────────────────┘
   
   AI PICKS ONE AT RANDOM → You're disappointed

The fix:

Replace subjective words with objective criteria.

✅ "Rewrite this email with:

•A formal greeting (Dear Mr./Ms.)

•No contractions (don't → do not)

•One clear ask per paragraph

•A professional closing with my full name"

Problem 2: Context Starvation ("I'm Not a Mind Reader")

Symptoms:

•Response makes assumptions that are wrong for your situation

•Output is generic instead of tailored to your needs

•You find yourself thinking "but that's not what I meant"

Root cause:

The AI doesn't know what you know. It's missing critical background information.

What the AI sees vs. what you see:

   WHAT YOU KNOW                 WHAT AI KNOWS
   ┌──────────────────┐         ┌──────────────────┐
   │ • Your industry  │         │                  │
   │ • Your audience  │         │   ONLY WHAT'S    │
   │ • Your goals     │   →     │   IN THE PROMPT  │
   │ • Past attempts  │         │                  │
   │ • Constraints    │         │                  │
   │ • Preferences    │         │                  │
   └──────────────────┘         └──────────────────┘
           │                            │
           │       GAP = BAD OUTPUT     │
           └────────────────────────────┘

The fix:

Front-load your prompts with context. Pretend you're briefing a new employee.

❌ "Write a social media post about our new feature"

✅ "Context: I'm the marketing manager at a B2B SaaS company that makes project management software. Our audience is operations managers at mid-size companies (100-500 employees). We're launching a new feature that automates status reports.

Task: Write a LinkedIn post announcing this feature. Focus on the time-saving benefit. Keep it under 150 words. End with a question to drive engagement."

Problem 3: Scope Mismatch ("Too Much or Too Little")

Symptoms for TOO MUCH:

•Output is overwhelming and unfocused

•Quality is diluted across too many things

•You only needed part of what you got

Symptoms for TOO LITTLE:

•Output is too shallow or surface-level

•Missing critical details

•Feels incomplete

The scope spectrum:

  TOO LITTLE ◄────────────────────────► TOO MUCH
       │                                      │
       ▼                                      ▼
  Shallow,                              Overwhelming,
  unhelpful                             unfocused
  
  "Summarize                            "Write a complete
   this in                               marketing strategy
   one word"                             for my business"
                    
                    ┌─────────────┐
                    │  JUST RIGHT │
                    │             │
                    │ Focused yet │
                    │ complete    │
                    └─────────────┘

The fix:

Be explicit about depth and breadth.

✅ "Give me a detailed breakdown of the top 3 options—not a brief overview, but enough detail that I could take action on any of them. Include pros, cons, and a recommendation."

✅ "Keep this high-level—I just need to understand the concept, not the implementation details."

Problem 4: Expectation Violations ("AI Can't Do That")

Symptoms:

•Response contains made-up information

•AI confidently states things that are wrong

•Output requires real-time data or personal knowledge

Root cause:

You're asking for something outside the AI's capabilities.

What AI CAN'T do reliably:

   ┌───────────────────────────────────────────┐
   │           AI LIMITATION ZONES             │
   ├───────────────────────────────────────────┤
   │                                           │
   │  ⚠️  Real-time information (stocks, news) │
   │  ⚠️  Future predictions (specific)        │
   │  ⚠️  Personal data it wasn't given        │
   │  ⚠️  Highly specialized/niche facts       │
   │  ⚠️  Math with large numbers              │
   │  ⚠️  Counting words/characters exactly    │
   │                                           │
   └───────────────────────────────────────────┘

The fix:

Acknowledge limitations in your prompt.

✅ "Based on general best practices (not real-time data), what would be a reasonable range for..."

✅ "I know you might not have specific data on this—give me your best general framework based on similar situations."

✅ "If you're not certain about something, say so rather than making it up."

The Ultimate Debugging Checklist

Next time ChatGPT disappoints you, run through this:

1. Clarity Check

•Did I use any vague words? (good, better, nice, professional)

•Could my request be interpreted multiple ways?

•Did I define what success looks like?

2. Context Check

•Did I share who I am and what I'm trying to accomplish?

•Did I mention my audience/target?

•Did I include relevant constraints?

3. Scope Check

•Did I specify how detailed I want the response?

•Am I asking for too many things at once?

•Did I set length expectations?

4. Reality Check

•Am I asking for something AI can actually do?

•Do I need real-time or personal data?

•Should I fact-check this output?

Quick Fixes You Can Try Right Now

When you get a bad response, don't start over. Try these repair prompts:

Problem	Repair Prompt
Too generic	"Make this more specific to [my situation]"
Too long	"Condense this to the 3 most important points"
Wrong tone	"Rewrite this in a [casual/formal] tone"
Missing depth	"Expand on point #2 with specific examples"
Wrong focus	"Focus more on [X] and less on [Y]"
Hallucinating	"Which parts of this are you uncertain about?"

Remember: It's a Conversation

ChatGPT isn't a vending machine where you insert a prompt and get a perfect answer. It's more like a conversation with a very knowledgeable but literal-minded colleague.

When things go wrong, don't blame the AI—refine your communication. The better you get at diagnosing problems, the better your prompts become.

Share this article

PREVIOUSCommon Prompt Mistakes & How to Fix Them NEXTPrompt Engineering Best Practices 2025